(772) 877-0268
To view the website in your native language click one of the flags

Real estate investing · 2026 and 2027

Is it a good time to buy investment property? Reading a rate-driven market

Mortgage rates climbed back above 7% in 2026, and fewer buyers can compete. On the Treasure Coast that turned the condo market into a buyer's market and left single-family homes balanced. For an investor that means room to negotiate, but only if the rent covers a 7% payment. Here is how to read the market, run the numbers and decide whether to buy now or wait for 2027.

  • Jeannie Jacobson, RE/MAX Gold
  • FL License SL3516612
  • English and Spanish
Months of supply · Oct 2026
7.9St. Lucie County condos and townhouses
7.28%30-year average, Nov 19
49days to contract, STL houses
94.7%of list price, STL condos

The short answer

Is now a good time to buy a rental property?

Yes, if the deal works at today's rate. Not if it only works after a refinance.

In October 2026, St. Lucie County condos had 7.9 months of supply, a buyer's market, while single-family homes sat at a balanced 5.4 months and Martin County houses at 3.9. Fewer buyers can compete at 7%, which gives investors room to negotiate price, repairs and credits that were rare in 2021 and 2022. The catch is the cost of money. Investment property loans price above owner-occupied loans, so many homes that look cheap still run negative each month. Buy the property whose rent covers the payment now, treat any 2027 rate drop as a bonus, and walk away from the ones that do not.

Mortgage rate7.28%30-year fixed average, up from 6.26% a year earlier. Investment loans price higher.Freddie Mac PMMS, Nov 19, 2026
Condo supply7.9Months of supply, St. Lucie County condos and townhouses. Above six favors buyers.Florida Realtors, Oct 2026
Median sale price
$399,950
St. Lucie County single-family homes, October 2026, up 2.6% in a year. Prices are firm; the leverage is in the terms.Florida Realtors, Oct 2026
DOWN15%minimum
Minimum down payment on a one-unit investment purchase with a conventional loan; 25% for two to four units.Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix, Aug 2026

A buyer's market is about leverage, not about prices falling forever. Medians are still slightly up from a year ago. What changed is who sets the terms: inspection repairs, closing credits, price cuts and more time to secure financing.

This page is a decision guide for buying rentals in 2026 and 2027. For the landlord side, from cap rates to leases and 1031 exchanges, see Jeannie's Port St. Lucie investment property guide.

Is it a buyer's or seller's market right now?

Four numbers that tell you who holds the leverage

Headlines say "buyer's market" or "seller's market" as if it were a switch. It is a range, and it moves by price band and neighborhood. These four signals, read together, tell you how hard you can negotiate on a specific home.

01

Months of supply

Active listings divided by the homes that sold last month. Under five months favors sellers, five to six is balanced, above six favors buyers. St. Lucie condos: 7.9 in October 2026, down from 9.1 a year earlier.

02

Days to contract

How long a listing sits before it goes under contract. When the median stretches past two months, most sellers have already seen their first offers fall short. St. Lucie houses: 49 days. St. Lucie condos: 56 days, down from 113 a year earlier.

03

Sale-to-list ratio

The share of the last list price a home actually sells for. Below 96% means room on price, before any credits at closing. St. Lucie houses: 95.9%. Condos: 94.7%. Martin condos: 93.4%.

04

Price cuts and new listings

A rising share of listings with a price reduction, and new listings outpacing sales, both point toward buyers. Watch them by street, not by county. In St. Lucie, house listings rose 0.4% in a year while new pending sales fell 21.7%, from 512 to 401.

Read together, the October 2026 numbers show a split market. Condos and townhouses in St. Lucie County lean clearly toward buyers. Single-family homes in St. Lucie County are balanced, with sellers accepting a little under 96% of their original price. In Martin County, single-family supply fell to 3.9 months, so houses around Stuart and Palm City still favor sellers. Higher rates slowed sales everywhere: St. Lucie house sales fell 19.5% from a year earlier and Martin house sales 17.7%.

Condos and townhomes tell a different story from single-family homes. New Florida condo safety laws, after the 2021 Surfside collapse, require structural inspections and fully funded reserves, and many older associations passed large special assessments. That pushed condo supply far higher than house supply. For an investor it means both the best discounts and the biggest hidden costs sit in the same segment. For the owner-occupant view of the same market, see is it a buyer's market in Port St. Lucie.

Sources: Florida Realtors county market reports for St. Lucie and Martin counties, October 2026, released November 16, 2026. Balance thresholds follow the Florida Realtors rule of thumb. Read November 19, 2026.

Rental property calculator

Does the deal work at today's rate?

Enter a price, a rent and your costs. The calculator shows the monthly cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash return and DSCR, then what a lower rate in 2027 would add if you could refinance. The preset is a sample three-bedroom house near the St. Lucie median price, with rent near HUD's 2027 benchmark and a rate a little above the national average, since investors pay more. Replace every number with the real ones for the home you are looking at.

Down payment 25%
Monthly cash flow$0
Cap rate0%
Cash-on-cash0%
DSCR0
Debt service coveragelenders often want 1.0 to 1.25
1.01.25
Loan amount
$0
Principal and interest
$0
Net operating income, yearly
$0
Cash to close, with about 3% costs
$0
Payment saved after a refinance
$0
Cash flow after a refinance
$0

A planning estimate, not financial, tax or lending advice. It assumes a 30-year fixed loan and ignores refinance costs, appreciation, principal paydown and income taxes. Rates for investment properties vary by lender, credit score, down payment and property type. Get a written quote and a rent estimate before you make an offer.

1

Cap rate ignores the loan

Cap rate is net operating income divided by price. It compares properties on equal footing, cash or financed. In a high-rate year, a cap rate below the mortgage rate usually means negative leverage: borrowing makes the return worse, not better.

2

Cash-on-cash is your money

Cash-on-cash return is the yearly cash flow divided by the cash you put in. It is the number that tells you whether the down payment would earn more here or somewhere else, such as a money market fund.

3

DSCR is the lender's test

Debt service coverage ratio is rent divided by principal, interest, taxes, insurance and HOA. A DSCR loan qualifies on this number instead of your personal income, and many lenders look for at least 1.0, with better pricing near 1.25.

Investment property interest rates

Why a rental costs more to finance than your own home

The rate you see on the news is for an owner-occupied home with a strong credit score. A rental property carries more risk for the lender, so the price of the loan, the down payment and the reserves all change. Plan around the investment rate, not the headline one.

Extra price adjustment on an investment purchase, as a share of the loan

Primary residence0%
Investment, 25% to 30% down2.125%
Investment, 20% to 25% down3.375%
Investment, 15% to 20% down4.125%

Fannie Mae adds this investment-property adjustment on top of the credit-score charges every borrower pays. Lenders usually turn it into a higher interest rate rather than a fee, which is why the rate you are quoted for a rental is above the 7.28% national average.

Down payment

At least 15% down for a one-unit rental and 25% for two to four units on a conventional loan, compared with as little as 3% for a home you live in. Gifts cannot be used toward an investment purchase.

Seller credits

Conventional rules cap what a seller can pay toward your costs on an investment property at 2% of the price, against 3% to 9% for a primary residence. Ask for the rest of a discount as a lower price.

Reserves

Expect to show six months of payments in reserve for the rental, plus 2% to 6% of the balances on any other financed homes you own, depending on how many you have.

Counting the rent

Lenders count 75% of the expected rent toward qualifying, and 50% for a short-term rental. Rent counts as income only with 12 months of landlord experience; otherwise it can only offset the payment.

DSCR loans have become the fastest-growing way investors finance rentals, and Google searches for them in Florida rose about 90% over the past year. A DSCR loan is a private loan underwritten mainly on the property's rent against its payment, not on your tax returns. Because a loan for a rental you will not live in counts as business credit under federal rules, it falls outside the consumer ability-to-repay rule, and terms vary widely by lender. That suits self-employed buyers, owners of several rentals and buyers closing in an LLC. The trade-offs are a higher rate, a larger down payment, and prepayment penalties that can make an early refinance expensive. Read the prepayment clause before you count on a 2027 refinance.

Other options include a portfolio loan from a local bank or credit union, a cash purchase followed by a delayed-financing refinance, and buying a two- to four-unit property and living in one unit, which lets you use owner-occupied pricing. For the current rate picture on owner-occupied loans, see Jeannie's guide to Port St. Lucie mortgage rates.

Sources: Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix (August 5, 2026); Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02 interested party contributions, B3-4.1-01 reserves and B3-3.8 rental income (September 2, 2026); Fannie Mae LLPA Matrix (September 30, 2026); Freddie Mac PMMS (November 19, 2026); CFPB Regulation Z 1026.3(a). Read November 19, 2026.

Real estate investing in a high interest rate environment

Six ways investors use a buyer's market to beat the rate

When sellers compete for fewer buyers, the most valuable concessions are the ones that lower your payment, not just your price. A $10,000 price cut and a $10,000 rate buydown cost the seller the same, but they do very different things to your monthly cash flow.

Ask for a rate buydown, paid by the seller

Seller credits can pay discount points that lower your rate for the life of the loan, or fund a temporary 2-1 buydown that cuts the rate by two points in year one and one point in year two. On a conventional investment loan the seller can contribute up to 2% of the price, so use that 2% where it lowers the payment most and take the rest of the discount as price.

Builder incentives

New-construction builders in Port St. Lucie and Fort Pierce often offer below-market rates through their own lenders and closing-cost credits. Some programs are limited to buyers who will live in the home, so confirm that investors qualify.

Assume a low-rate loan

FHA, VA and USDA loans are assumable. Taking over a 3% loan can change the math entirely, but you must cover the seller's equity in cash and the lender must approve you. See the assumable mortgage guide.

Negotiate repairs and terms

Longer inspection windows, repair credits, an appliance or roof allowance and a later closing all have value. In a slow market they are easier to win than a big price cut.

Trade up with a 1031 exchange

An investor selling in this market can defer capital gains by buying a like-kind property within the IRS deadlines: 45 days to identify, 180 days to close. A buyer's market makes the replacement easier to find.

Buy now, refinance later, with care

"Marry the house, date the rate" works only if the house pays for itself before the refinance. Rates may not fall as much as forecast, a refinance has closing costs, and DSCR loans can carry prepayment penalties. Underwrite at today's rate; let a lower rate be upside, not the plan.

Sources: Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02 (2% cap on interested party contributions for investment properties); IRS Instructions for Form 8824 (45- and 180-day exchange deadlines); Google Trends, Florida, past 12 months. Read November 19, 2026.

Will interest rates go down in 2027?

Three rate paths, and what each one means for a rental

The Federal Reserve held rates through the first half of 2026, raised them in September and held in October, and the 30-year mortgage rate rose about a point in a year. Neither of the two main forecasters expects a return to 6% in 2027. Test every deal against all three paths below.

30-year mortgage rate: 2026 path and Fannie Mae forecast for 2027 5.5% 6.0% 6.5% 7.0% 7.5% 8.0% MBA: above 7% through 2027 Q1 26 6.1% Q2 26 Q3 26 Q4 26 7.2% Q1 27 Q2 27 Q3 27 Q4 27 7.2% 7.28% Nov 19
Quarterly averages of the 30-year fixed rate as published in Fannie Mae's November 2026 forecast, with its 2027 forecast dashed. The shaded band is the MBA's view that rates stay above 7% through 2027. The red point is the latest weekly Freddie Mac average. Forecasts are estimates, not promises.
Rates fall

Back below 6.5%

Refinancing becomes possible and more buyers return, so prices firm up and the discounts of 2026 shrink. Investors who bought with a seller-paid buydown in 2026 gain twice: a lower price locked in and a cheaper loan later.

Rates hold · the base case

Around 7% to 7.5%, the forecast

The buyer's market lasts longer, and negotiating power stays with you. The rentals that make sense are the ones with positive cash flow at today's rate, a realistic rent and an insurance quote in hand.

Rates rise

Above 8%

A deal that only worked after a refinance turns into a long negative carry. This is the scenario a cash reserve and a fixed-rate loan protect you from. Avoid adjustable loans you could not carry at their cap.

Fannie Mae's same forecast expects national home prices to rise only 0.6% in 2027 and total home sales to stay near 2026 levels. For an investor, that combination argues against buying on the hope of quick appreciation or a quick refinance. The return has to come from rent, from a price negotiated well below the asking price, and from holding long enough for the loan balance to fall.

The flip side is that a forecast of flat rates is also a forecast of a slow market. If rates stay near 7%, the negotiating room investors have now is likely to last through much of 2027, especially for condos. There is no prize for buying the first week; there is a cost to buying a home that runs short every month.

Sources: Fannie Mae Economic and Strategic Research, Housing Forecast, November 12, 2026; MBA Mortgage Finance Forecast, October 11, 2026; Freddie Mac PMMS, November 19, 2026; Federal Reserve FOMC statements, September 16 and October 28, 2026. Read November 19, 2026.

Risks of buying investment property now

What can sink a Florida rental in 2026

Price and rate get the attention, but the costs that turn a good rental into a bad one in Florida are usually insurance, association fees and time without a tenant. Price each of them before you make an offer.

Roof agethe line that moves the premium most

Insurance

A landlord policy costs more than a homeowner policy, and older roofs, older electrical and plumbing, and distance to the coast push it higher. Ask for the four-point and wind mitigation reports and get a written quote before your inspection period ends.

7.9 mo.condo supply, St. Lucie County

Condo assessments

Florida laws passed after the 2021 Surfside collapse require structural inspections and reserve funding in many older buildings, and some associations have raised dues or passed special assessments. Read the reserve study, the inspection reports and the minutes before you offer.

−3.8%HUD 3-bedroom benchmark, Vero area, 2027

Vacancy and rent growth

Rents do not rise everywhere. HUD's 2027 three-bedroom benchmark rose 15.7% in the Port St. Lucie metro but fell 3.8% in the Sebastian-Vero Beach area. Use leased comparables, budget for a month or more between tenants and do not assume next year's rent.

5%tourist tax in all three counties

Rules on short-term rentals

Stays of six months or less owe Florida sales tax, the county surtax and a 5% tourist development tax. Port St. Lucie requires a business tax receipt, Fort Pierce runs its own registration program, and many associations ban short stays. Confirm the rules for the exact address.

There is one tax change in the investor's favor. Florida's Amendment 3, approved in November 2026, lowers the yearly cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property, including rentals, from 10% to 5% for non-school taxes starting in 2027. It does not lower the tax on a rental today, but it limits how fast the assessed value can climb. See Florida Amendment 3 explained.

Flood risk deserves its own line. Waterfront and low-lying homes may need flood insurance even outside a mapped high-risk zone, and lenders require it inside one. Ask for the elevation certificate and a flood quote early; for homes on the water, see the waterfront homes guide.

Sources: Florida Realtors St. Lucie County condo report, October 2026; HUD Fair Market Rents FY2026 and FY2027 (effective October 1, 2026); Florida Office of Economic and Demographic Research, 2026 local option tourist tax rates; City of Port St. Lucie Business Tax Division; City of Fort Pierce short-term rental program. Read November 19, 2026.

Best places to buy rental property on the Treasure Coast

Four markets, four different investor stories

The Treasure Coast is not one market. Entry price, rent, tenant pool and insurance cost all change between Port St. Lucie, Fort Pierce, Stuart and Vero Beach. HUD's 2027 benchmark rent for a three-bedroom is $2,801 in the Port St. Lucie metro, which covers St. Lucie and Martin counties, and $1,882 in the Vero Beach area. These are program benchmarks that include utilities, not a promise of what a specific home will rent for.

SellerBalancedBuyer 3.9Martin houses 5.4St. Lucie houses · Martin condos 7.9St. Lucie condos
036912 months
  • 3.9 Martin houses
  • 5.4 St. Lucie houses
  • 5.4 Martin condos
  • 7.9 St. Lucie condos

Port St. Lucie

5.4months of supply, St. Lucie houses

Newer single-family homes on city lots, steady family and retiree demand, and a large share of new construction that competes with resales. Balanced for houses; investors win on terms and builder incentives more than on price.

Port St. Lucie landlord guide

Fort Pierce

7.9months of supply, St. Lucie condos

The lowest entry prices in the region, older housing stock and the county's condo and townhouse buyer's market, from downtown to Hutchinson Island. More negotiating room, more due diligence on roofs, flood zones and associations.

Fort Pierce investment guide

Stuart and Jensen Beach

3.9months of supply, Martin houses

Higher prices, waterfront demand and the tightest single-family market on the Treasure Coast. Fewer bargains on houses, but Martin County condos sit at a balanced 5.4 months with sellers taking about 93% of their original price.

Vero Beach

$1,882HUD 3-bedroom benchmark, 2027

A separate metro area with a seasonal, older population and listings that took a median of 74 days to sell in October. HUD's rent benchmark fell for 2027, so check leased comparables closely before you count on rent growth.

Cash buyers matter in this market. In October 2026, 31% of St. Lucie County house sales and half of Martin County house sales closed in cash. When you finance, you compete with those buyers, so a strong pre-approval, a short inspection period and flexible closing dates can matter as much as price.

Palm City, Jensen Beach and the barrier islands each behave like their own small market. Waterfront homes, golf communities and age-restricted communities carry their own rules on leasing, so ask for the association documents early. For golf and club communities, see the golf course homes guide.

Sources: Florida Realtors county reports for St. Lucie and Martin, October 2026; HUD Fair Market Rents FY2027 county file; Realtor.com listing data for the Sebastian-Vero Beach metro via FRED, October 2026. Read November 19, 2026.

Taxes on Florida rental property

The tax side of a rental, in five lines

Taxes do not make a bad deal good, but they change the after-tax return of every deal. These are the rules most Florida rental owners meet in the first year. Confirm your own situation with a CPA.

  1. 0%

    No Florida personal income tax

    Florida has no state income tax on individuals, so rental profit is taxed only at the federal level. That matters most to investors moving from high-tax states.

  2. 27.5

    Depreciation over 27.5 years

    The IRS lets you deduct the cost of a residential rental building, not the land, over 27.5 years. On paper it often turns a small positive cash flow into a tax loss.

  3. 5%

    Non-homestead assessment cap

    A rental does not get the homestead exemption. From 2027, its assessed value for non-school taxes can rise at most 5% a year under Amendment 3, down from 10%.

  4. 11%+

    Short-term rental taxes

    Rentals of six months or less owe the 6% state sales tax, the county surtax and a 5% tourist development tax in St. Lucie, Martin and Indian River counties, collected by each county.

  5. 1031

    Like-kind exchanges

    Selling one investment property and buying another under Section 1031 can defer the capital gains tax and depreciation recapture, if a qualified intermediary holds the money and you meet the deadlines.

Sources: IRS Publication 527 (27.5-year recovery period); IRS Instructions for Form 8824; Florida Constitution Art. VII s. 4 as amended by Amendment 3 (2026); Florida Office of Economic and Demographic Research, 2026 tourist and discretionary sales surtax rates. Read November 19, 2026.

Long-term, mid-term or short-term rental?

The same house, three different businesses

How you rent the home changes the income, the work, the taxes and even how much of the rent a lender will count. Decide which business you are buying before you choose the house.

12-month lease

Long-term rental

Tenant
Local families, workers and retirees
Income
Steady, one payment a month
Work
Lowest; a manager is optional
Sales and tourist tax
None on leases over six months
Rent a lender counts
75% of market rent

The simplest fit for a 7% loan, because the income is predictable and the costs are easy to estimate.

1 to 6 months

Mid-term rental

Tenant
Snowbirds, traveling nurses, relocations
Income
Higher monthly rent, seasonal gaps
Work
Furnished home, more turnovers
Sales and tourist tax
Yes: stays of six months or less are transient
Rent a lender counts
Treated case by case

Strong demand in winter on the Treasure Coast, but many investors forget that Florida taxes these stays like a hotel room.

Nights and weeks

Short-term rental

Tenant
Vacationers and visitors
Income
Highest potential, most variable
Work
Cleaning, guests, licensing
Sales and tourist tax
6% state, county surtax, 5% tourist tax
Rent a lender counts
50%, and only where it is legal

Works only where the city and the association allow it. Check the documents before you run the numbers, not after.

In Florida, any rental of six months or less is a transient rental for sales tax, so both mid-term and short-term stays owe the state sales tax, the county surtax and the county tourist development tax. The owner or the booking platform must register and remit them. Leases longer than six months are exempt.

Associations often decide the question for you. Many condo and homeowner associations require minimum lease terms, limit the number of leases a year or require approval of each tenant. Some communities also cap the share of homes that can be rented. Those rules can change the value of a home to an investor more than any price cut.

Sources: Florida Statutes 212.03 (transient rentals) and Florida Office of Economic and Demographic Research 2026 tourist tax rates; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.8-02 and B3-3.8-03 (September 2, 2026). Read November 19, 2026.

How to evaluate a rental property

A seven-step check before you make an offer

This is the order Jeannie suggests for any rental in a buyer's market. Each step can end the deal early, which is the point: the cheapest mistake is the house you never bought.

  1. Get a real rent number

    Pull leased comparables from the last six months, not asking rents. Check how long similar homes sat before they leased.

  2. Quote insurance first

    Ask for the four-point and wind mitigation reports and get a written quote before the inspection period ends. Roof age drives the price.

  3. Read the association documents

    For a condo or HOA, read the budget, reserves, the latest structural reports and any pending assessments. Confirm the rules allow rentals and how often.

  4. Price the loan as an investor

    Get an investment-property quote, with points and adjustments, at your real credit score and down payment.

  5. Run it at today's rate

    Use the calculator above. If cash flow is negative at today's rate, ask what price or buydown would make it positive.

  6. Ask for the concession that matters

    Use the slow market to request a seller-paid buydown or credits, repairs and more time, instead of chasing only the price.

  7. Keep a reserve

    Hold at least six months of payments and a repair fund. In Florida, a roof, an air conditioner or a hurricane deductible can arrive in the same year.

Questions investors ask

Buying investment property in 2026 and 2027, answered

Straight answers to the questions investors ask most about rates, buyer's markets and rentals on the Treasure Coast. Have one about a specific property? Ask Jeannie directly.

Is it a good time to buy investment property in 2026?

It can be, if the property produces positive cash flow at today's interest rate. Late 2026 favors buyers on the Treasure Coast: there is more inventory, homes take longer to sell and sellers are offering credits and rate buydowns. The risk is buying a home that only makes sense after rates fall. Run the numbers at the current investment-property rate, and treat any future refinance as upside.

Is it better to buy a rental property now or wait until rates drop?

Waiting for lower rates often means competing with more buyers at higher prices. Buying now gives you negotiating power, but a higher payment. A practical rule: buy now only if the rent covers the payment and expenses at today's rate, and keep a cash reserve. If a deal needs a lower rate to work, waiting is the safer choice.

Is it a buyer's or seller's market right now in Florida?

It depends on the segment. In October 2026, St. Lucie County condos and townhouses had 7.9 months of supply, a buyer's market. St. Lucie County single-family homes had 5.4 months, which is balanced, and Martin County single-family homes had 3.9 months, which still favors sellers. Statewide, Florida single-family homes had 4.6 months and condos 8.0 months.

What does months of supply mean in real estate?

Months of supply is how long it would take to sell every active listing at the current pace of sales, if no new homes were listed. Under four months generally favors sellers, four to six months is balanced and more than six months favors buyers. It is one of the clearest measures of who has leverage in a negotiation.

Are interest rates higher for investment property?

Yes. Lenders price loans for rental properties higher than loans for a primary residence because they carry more risk. The difference comes from loan-level price adjustments, which grow with a smaller down payment or lower credit score. Investment loans also require larger down payments and cash reserves. Ask lenders for a quote marked as investment property, not the advertised owner-occupied rate.

How much down payment do I need for an investment property?

With a conventional loan sold to Fannie Mae, the minimum is 15% down for a one-unit investment property and 25% for a two- to four-unit property. Gifts cannot be used for an investment purchase, and you will usually need six months of payments in reserve. DSCR and portfolio lenders set their own minimums, which are often higher.

What is a DSCR loan?

A debt service coverage ratio loan qualifies a rental property on its rent instead of the borrower's personal income. The lender divides the expected rent by the monthly principal, interest, taxes, insurance and HOA dues. Many lenders want a ratio of at least 1.0, with better pricing near 1.25. DSCR loans usually carry higher rates and down payments than conventional loans, and many include prepayment penalties.

What is a good cap rate for a rental property?

There is no single good cap rate; it depends on the property, the neighborhood and the cost of money. In a high-rate year, compare the cap rate with your mortgage rate. If the cap rate is lower than the rate you borrow at, borrowing reduces your return, which is called negative leverage. Cap rates also tend to be lower in newer, lower-maintenance neighborhoods and higher where risk and upkeep are greater.

What is the 1% rule for rental property?

The 1% rule says the monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price, for example $3,000 a month on a $300,000 home. It is a quick screen, not an analysis, and few Florida single-family homes meet it at today's prices. A full calculation with taxes, insurance, vacancy, management and repairs, like the calculator on this page, tells you far more.

Will mortgage rates go down in 2027?

The main forecasters do not expect a large drop. Fannie Mae's November 2026 forecast puts the 30-year fixed rate at 7.2% in every quarter of 2027, and the Mortgage Bankers Association expects rates to stay above 7% through 2027. The Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate in September 2026. Forecasts change often, so plan around today's rate.

Should I buy now and refinance later?

Only if the property works without the refinance. Refinancing costs money in closing costs, may require a new appraisal and depends on rates actually falling. Some DSCR loans also charge a prepayment penalty in the first few years. If the deal is cash-flow positive at today's rate, a later refinance is a bonus. If not, you are betting on a forecast.

Can I ask the seller to pay for a rate buydown on an investment property?

Yes, as part of the offer, and in a buyer's market sellers often agree. Seller credits can pay discount points or fund a temporary buydown. On a conventional investment loan, Fannie Mae caps seller contributions at 2% of the price, compared with 3% to 9% for a primary residence, so ask for the rest of any discount as a lower price.

Is Port St. Lucie a good place to invest in real estate?

Port St. Lucie has been one of Florida's fastest-growing cities, with a large share of newer single-family homes, steady demand from families and retirees and lower entry prices than Palm Beach County. The trade-offs are rising insurance costs, competition from new construction and rents that have flattened as new supply arrived. Whether it is a good investment depends on the specific home's rent, price and insurance.

Are condos a good investment in Florida right now?

Condos carry the largest discounts and the largest hidden risks. Florida's condo safety laws require structural inspections and fully funded reserves, and many older buildings have passed special assessments. A condo can still work for an investor if the association is well funded, the inspections are done and rentals are allowed. Read the budget, reserve study and minutes before you offer.

How much does insurance cost on a Florida rental?

It varies widely with roof age, construction, elevation and distance to the coast, so get a written quote before your inspection period ends. A landlord policy, often called a DP-3, costs more than a homeowner policy and does not cover the tenant's belongings. Wind mitigation and four-point inspections can lower the premium. In flood zones, lenders also require flood insurance.

Do I pay property tax on a rental in Florida?

Yes. Rentals do not qualify for the homestead exemption, so they are taxed on their full assessed value. Starting in 2027, Florida Amendment 3 limits yearly increases in a non-homestead property's assessed value to 5% for non-school taxes, down from 10%. Rates and special assessments still vary by address.

Can I do short-term rentals in Port St. Lucie?

Port St. Lucie requires a business tax receipt for any business operated in the city, and the state requires short stays to collect sales and tourist taxes. Fort Pierce has its own short-term rental registration program. Many homeowners and condo associations limit or ban short-term rentals, so check the documents and confirm the current rules with the city before you buy.

How does depreciation work on a rental property?

The IRS lets you deduct the cost of a residential rental building, not the land, over 27.5 years. That deduction can offset rental income on paper, which lowers your taxable profit. When you sell, the depreciation you claimed is generally recaptured and taxed, unless you defer it with a 1031 exchange. A CPA can confirm how it applies to you.

What is a 1031 exchange?

A 1031 exchange lets an investor sell one investment property and buy another like-kind property while deferring capital gains tax. You must identify replacement properties within 45 days of the sale, close within 180 days and use a qualified intermediary to hold the money. It does not apply to a primary residence.

What is a good cash-on-cash return?

Cash-on-cash return is your yearly cash flow divided by the cash you invested, including the down payment and closing costs. Many investors compare it with what the same money would earn in a savings account or bond. When safe yields are high, a rental needs a strong reason, such as long-term appreciation or tax benefits, to justify a lower cash return.

How do I find investment properties in a buyer's market?

Look at listings that have been on the market longest and at homes with recent price cuts, and ask about seller motivation. Expired listings and new-construction inventory homes can also offer room to negotiate. A local agent can set up alerts for price reductions and days on market in the neighborhoods you want.

Can rental income help me qualify for an investment property loan?

Yes, with limits. On a conventional loan, the lender counts 75% of the expected rent from the appraiser's rent schedule or a lease, and 50% for a short-term rental. If you have less than 12 months of experience managing rentals, the rent can only offset the new payment, not add to your income.

What is the fair market rent in Port St. Lucie for 2027?

HUD's fiscal year 2027 Fair Market Rents, effective October 1, 2026, are $2,069 for a two-bedroom and $2,801 for a three-bedroom in the Port St. Lucie metro, which includes St. Lucie and Martin counties. In the Sebastian-Vero Beach metro they are $1,542 and $1,882. These are program benchmarks that include utilities, not market asking rents.

Is it better to pay cash for a rental when rates are above 7%?

Paying cash removes the payment risk and often wins negotiations, but it ties up money that could earn interest elsewhere. Compare the property's cap rate with what the cash would earn safely. If the cap rate is lower than the mortgage rate, financing makes the return worse, so a larger down payment or cash can make sense. Some investors buy with cash and refinance later if rates fall.

Should I buy a condo or a house as a rental?

In October 2026, condos offered more negotiating room on the Treasure Coast, with 7.9 months of supply in St. Lucie County against 5.4 for houses. Condos carry association dues, rental restrictions and the risk of special assessments, while houses carry the full cost of the roof, insurance and upkeep. Compare the total monthly cost of each, not just the price.

What is negative leverage in real estate?

Negative leverage happens when the property's cap rate is lower than the interest rate on the loan. Each borrowed dollar costs more than it earns, so financing lowers the return on your cash instead of raising it. It was common in 2026 with mortgage rates above 7%, and it is the main reason to run the numbers before you buy.

Can I buy an investment property in an LLC?

Yes, but the loan changes. Conventional loans sold to Fannie Mae are made to individual borrowers, so investors who want to close in an LLC usually use a DSCR or portfolio lender, often with a personal guarantee. Talk to an attorney and a CPA about liability and taxes before choosing how to hold title.

Does Jeannie Jacobson help investors?

Yes. Jeannie Jacobson is a Realtor with RE/MAX Gold who works with buyers and sellers across Port St. Lucie, Stuart, Palm City, Jensen Beach, Fort Pierce and Vero Beach, in English and Spanish. She can pull rental comparables, help you estimate costs, and negotiate seller credits. Call (772) 877-0268 or book a consultation online.

General information about real estate investing, financing and taxes, current as of November 19, 2026. It is not financial, lending, legal or tax advice, and forecasts are not guarantees. Confirm your situation with a lender, a CPA and an attorney.

Your next step

Buy the rental that works today, not the one that needs 2027

Send Jeannie your budget, your financing plan and the kind of tenant you want. She will shortlist homes where the rent, insurance and taxes still add up at today's rates, and help you negotiate the credits a buyer's market makes possible.

Jeannie Jacobson · RE/MAX Gold (772) 877-0268

English and Spanish · Port St. Lucie, Stuart, Palm City, Jensen Beach, Fort Pierce and Vero Beach

Book an investor consultation Browse homes for sale 10850 S US Highway 1, Port St. Lucie, FL 34952 · About Jeannie

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.